Commissioner Peirce Implores the SEC to Rethink ESG Metrics

Apr 16, 2021

Reading Time : 1 min

Asserting that a prescriptive approach to ESG would be inconsistent with the SEC’s principles-based disclosure framework, Peirce argues that a single set of metrics would constrain decision making and impede creative thinking by boxing companies in with preset, government-articulated metrics. Unlike financial accounting, which lends itself to a common set of comparable metrics, Peirce notes that ESG factors are complex and not readily comparable across issuers and industries.

Peirce closes by contending that the addition of specific ESG metrics, which would presumably be responsive to the wide-ranging interests of a broad set of “stakeholders,” would mark a departure from fundamental aspects of the SEC’s disclosure framework. Further, she cautions that a stakeholder-focused disclosure regime would likely expand the jurisdictional reach of the Commission and have negative consequences on our capital markets.

Peirce’s latest critique follows her and fellow Republican Commissioner Elad Roisman’s March 2021 comments in which they questioned whether the SEC’s recent actions would have any real consequence, noting that the SEC cannot adopt new disclosure rules without undertaking a formal rulemaking process. Regardless, the recent actions suggest that more prescriptive disclosure rules—or at least more concrete guidance—to facilitate ESG and climate-related disclosure are on the horizon. Based on their response to last year’s amendments to the regulations governing management’s discussion and analysis (MD&A), in which they lamented the missed opportunity to standardize companies’ ESG and climate risks disclosure requirements, Democratic Commissioners Allison Herren Lee and Caroline Crenshaw appear poised to help newly confirmed Chair Gary Gensler spearhead these efforts.

Share This Insight

Previous Entries

Speaking Sustainability

June 30, 2025

The European Parliament and Council reached a provisional agreement (i.e., a post-consultation, non-binding political deal in relation to the final text of a legislative proposal) to streamline the European Union’s (EU) Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) on June 18, 2025. This is a key instrument to prevent carbon leakage and align trade policy with the EU’s climate goals. The changes are part of the EU’s broader sustainability legislative simplification package announced earlier this year. This proposal is intended to ease compliance burdens while maintaining the environmental integrity of the CBAM framework.

...

Read More

Speaking Sustainability

June 27, 2025

Key Topics in Akin’s June 2025 Speaking Sustainability - Legal & Regulatory Update

...

Read More

Speaking Sustainability

February 19, 2025

Wind energy projects along the coasts are facing uncertainty due to President Trump’s Presidential Memorandum1 issued on January 20, “Temporary Withdrawal of All Areas on the Outer Continental Shelf from Offshore Wind Leasing and Review of the Federal Government’s Leasing and Permitting Practices for Wind Projects.” This Memorandum introduces substantial policy changes that impact both onshore and offshore wind development.

...

Read More

Speaking Sustainability

February 14, 2025

Key topics in Akin’s February 2025 Speaking Sustainability - Legal & Regulatory Update include:

...

Read More

Speaking Sustainability

January 24, 2025

Beginning on Monday, there have been a flurry of executive orders from the Trump administration reversing Biden-era energy policies, emphasizing oil and gas production, lifting the liquified natural gas (LNG) export permitting pause and withdrawing from all accords and commitments under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) including the Paris climate agreement. The orders also target electric vehicles (EVs), wind energy, international climate aid and the use of the social cost of carbon in agency decision making. For close tracking of these orders and more to come, visit the Akin Trump Executive Order tracker. Concurrently, President Trump’s nominees for the Department of the Interior (DOI), Department of Energy (DOE) and Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) have each passed their initial rounds of committee confirmation votes, and now await votes before the Senate floor.

...

Read More

Speaking Sustainability

January 10, 2025

In the final days of his term, President Joe Biden has taken significant steps to solidify his administration’s climate legacy. The administration finalized rules for various clean energy tax credits established under the Inflation Reduction Act. However, these rules, intended to stimulate clean energy advancements through 2032, face opposition from Congressional Republicans, who are considering scaling back or repealing the credits through budget reconciliation.

...

Read More

Speaking Sustainability

December 19, 2024

The twilight hours of the Biden administration and the 118th Congress have been marked by intense legislative and regulatory activity, underscored by President-elect Trump’s derailment of last-minute congressional budget talks, and stalled progress on energy permitting reforms.

...

Read More

Speaking Sustainability

December 11, 2024

The Biden administration’s environmental policies and the future of infrastructure projects are facing pivotal legal challenges and political shifts. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit questioned the viability of the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) 2024 power plant emissions rule, particularly its reliance on carbon capture technology, while the 6th Circuit overturned the EPA’s rejection of Kentucky’s smog plan, which comes only three days after the EPA issued its defense of its “good neighbor” smog control plan responding to the Supreme Court’s decision to halt its implementation in June. Meanwhile, the Supreme Court’s handling of the first National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) case in some time, Seven County Infrastructure Coalition v. Eagle County, could substantially alter the scope of environmental reviews, with potential immediate implications for the oil & gas industry. These judicial reviews may be influenced by a potential change in administration and Congress, as Trump-era officials, including Vivek Ramaswamy, advocate for scaling back NEPA regulations to expedite infrastructure projects. Additionally, the Department of Energy’s recent clarity on liquified natural gas (LNG) export authorizations underscores the broader tension between expanding fossil fuel infrastructure and adhering to environmental regulations amidst a polarized political and legal landscape.

...

Read More

© 2025 Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP. All rights reserved. Attorney advertising. This document is distributed for informational use only; it does not constitute legal advice and should not be used as such. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Akin is the practicing name of Akin Gump LLP, a New York limited liability partnership authorized and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority under number 267321. A list of the partners is available for inspection at Eighth Floor, Ten Bishops Square, London E1 6EG. For more information about Akin Gump LLP, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP and other associated entities under which the Akin Gump network operates worldwide, please see our Legal Notices page.