New York Association of Public Power Files Complaint to Reduce Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation’s ROE

Feb 7, 2014

Reading Time : 2 min

FERC has not acted on the First Complaint or the MEUA Complaint. Although the FPA directs FERC to act “speedily” on complaints, the statutory time limit for action does not come into play until the proceeding is set for hearing.5 Because the Commission has chosen not to take any action on the ROE complaints, they have remained in administrative limbo. Meanwhile, the Commission’s recent issuances on the related issue of incentive ROEs, which involve awarding a higher ROE to compensate a developer for undertaking risky transmission investments, have indicated a move towards lower ROEs.6

In addition to the NYAPP and MEUA complaints, there are numerous other pending complaints regarding transmission ROEs in Florida, New England, Colorado, and the Midwest.  In particular, two complaint proceedings relating to transmission rates under the ISO New England, Inc. (ISO-NE) OATT have been very closely watched by the industry. In August, the administrative law judge (ALJ) in one of the ISO-NE proceedings recommended that the base ROE for New England transmission owners be reduced from 11.14 percent to 9.7 percent.7 Please click here to read decision. FERC has not yet ruled on the ALJ’s initial decision.

The various complainants are not the only parties anxious for resolution.  In June 2013, the Working group for Investment in Reliable and Economic electric Systems (WIRES) petitioned FERC to issue a statement of policy on transmission ROEs that would provide “greater stability and predictability regarding regulated rates of return on equity.”8 WIRES’s petition drew a swarm of commenters, both supporting and opposing changes in FERC’s ROE policy. On December 5, 2013, FERC Commissioner John Norris expressed his own frustrations with the delay, stating that “[t]hese cases have lingered at FERC long enough and I think it's OK to start asking publicly, 'Where is our decision?”9


1 New York Association of Public Power, Compliant of the New York Association of Public Power Challenging Base Return on Equity, filed Feb. 6, 2014, Docket No. EL14-29-000.

2 New York Association of Public Power, Compliant of the New York Association of Public Power Challenging Base Return on Equity, filed Sept. 11, 2012, EL12-101-000.

3 Second Complaint at 16.

4 Municipal Electric Utilities Association of New York State, Complaint of the Municipal Electric Utilities Association of New York and Request for Fast Track Processing, filed Nov. 2, 2012, Docket No. EL13-16-000.

5 16 U.S.C. § 824e(b).

6 See e.g., Promoting Transmission Investment Through Pricing Reform, 141 FERC ¶ 61,129 (2012); Pepco Holdings, Inc., 139 FERC ¶ 61,444 at PP 12-13 (2012).

7 See Coakley v. Bangor Hydro-Electric Co., 144 FERC ¶ 63,012 (2013).

8 Statement of Policy on Electric Transmission Rates of Return on Equity, Petition for Statement of Policy at 1, filed June 26, 2013, Docket No. RM13-18-000.

9 Ester Whieldon, Norris Pushes for FERC Action on Contentious Utility Transmission ROE Complaints, SNL Electric Transmission Week, Dec. 16, 2013, at 2.

Share This Insight

Previous Entries

Speaking Energy

November 12, 2025

On November 7, 2025, the New York Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) and the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection (NJDEP) reversed their prior positions and approved Clean Water Act (CWA) Section 401 Water Quality Certifications and other environmental permits for the Transcontinental Gas Pipeline Company’s (Transco) Northeast Supply Enhancement Project (NESE). NESE is a 25-mile natural gas pipeline expansion project certificated by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) that is intended to deliver 400,000 dekatherms per day of natural gas produced in Pennsylvania to local distribution company customers in New York City through new facilities in Middlesex County, New Jersey and an underwater segment traversing the Raritan and Lower New York Bays.

...

Read More

Speaking Energy

November 6, 2025

The market for the direct procurement of energy by commercial and industrial buyers has been active in the U.S. for a decade.  In years past, buyers often engaged in such purchases on a voluntary basis to achieve their goals to use renewable energy.  These days, C&I buyers are turning to direct procurement or self-supply to obtain a reliable source of energy.  Sufficient and accessible energy from a local utility may not be available or may be materially delayed or trigger significant capital costs.  This is a material change driven in part by increased demand for electricity, including demand from data centers, EV infrastructure and industrial development.       

...

Read More

Speaking Energy

October 27, 2025

On October 23, 2025, the Secretary of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) directed the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) to conduct a rulemaking to assert jurisdiction over load interconnections to the bulk electric transmission system and establish standardized procedures for the interconnection of large loads.1 The Directive included an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking (ANOPR) that sets forth the legal justification for asserting jurisdiction over transmission-level load interconnections and fourteen principles that should inform FERC’s rulemaking process. The Secretary has directed FERC to take “final action” on the Directive no later than April 30, 2026.

...

Read More

Speaking Energy

October 24, 2025

On October 21, 2025, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) issued a final order (DOE/FECM Order No. 5264-A1) granting Venture Global CP2 LNG, LLC long-term authorization to export up to 1,446 billion cubic feet per year of domestically produced liquefied natural gas (LNG) from its Louisiana facility to countries without a free trade agreement with the United States (Non-FTA Countries). The final order follows a March 2025 Conditional Order,2 which issued while DOE was still completing its review of the agency’s 2024 LNG Export Study.3 The final order confirms that the project’s export volume and term authorization (through December 31, 2050) are unchanged, but provides for a three-year “make-up period” to allow export of any approved volume not shipped during the original term.

...

Read More

Speaking Energy

October 9, 2025

On October 1, 2025, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC or the Commission) issued Order No. 914 amending certain Commission regulations to incorporate a conditional sunset date in compliance with the Trump administration’s April 2025 Executive Order, “Zero-Based Regulatory Budgeting to Unleash American Energy” (the EO).

...

Read More

Speaking Energy

October 8, 2025

Akin is pleased to serve as a gold sponsor for Infocast’s Energy Independence Summit in Houston, October 21-23. Energy partner Charlie Ofner will moderate the Macroeconomics of Domestic Energy Independence panel, projects & energy transition partner Shariff Barakat will lead Opportunities in US Manufacturing: How Big, How Fast, How FEOC?, and counsel Taha Qureshi will guide the discussion on Cornerstones for Energy Independence: Investing in Grid Security & Cybersecurity.

...

Read More

Speaking Energy

October 6, 2025

As of October 6, 2025, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) continues to operate despite the lapse in appropriations that resulted in a government shutdown on October 1, 2025. While FERC receives appropriations from Congress, it primarily is self-funded through fees and charges obtained from the industries it regulates, offsetting its total costs. Hence, during prior government shutdowns in 2018 and 2013, the agency was able to continue operations. However, FERC published a plan for operating in the event of a lapse in appropriations on September 30, 2025, available here

...

Read More

Speaking Energy

September 8, 2025

On September 4, 2025, the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee convened a hearing to consider the nominations of Laura Swett and David LaCerte to serve as commissioners at the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC or Commission). Swett is a former FERC Staff that served as legal and policy advisor to former FERC Chairman Kevin McIntyre and Commission Bernard McNamee. LaCerte is an attorney in private practice that previously held positions at the Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board and the Louisiana Department of Veterans Affairs.

...

Read More

© 2025 Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP. All rights reserved. Attorney advertising. This document is distributed for informational use only; it does not constitute legal advice and should not be used as such. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Akin is the practicing name of Akin Gump LLP, a New York limited liability partnership authorized and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority under number 267321. A list of the partners is available for inspection at Eighth Floor, Ten Bishops Square, London E1 6EG. For more information about Akin Gump LLP, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP and other associated entities under which the Akin Gump network operates worldwide, please see our Legal Notices page.